I had just finished this book and was trying to explain to John a why I liked it and this is what came out:
“It’s a book that had it been a movie I would have loved it but because I liked the book I’d never see the movie, but do you know what I mean?”
Fortunately he did know what I meant.
Here is a translation for the rest of you. The book involved a lot of beating the bad guys up with big sticks, funny quippy sort of comments from the good guys, who weren’t all guys and weren’t an angelic type of good. The main character is a girl who’s quite adept at beating people up herself, and she has an interesting purple eyed cat.
As it turns out my favorite movies are the ones where good guys aren’t really that great and they make lots of quippy comments while they are running around blowing things up, which is always good because there is significantly less gore and guts.
I’m not a fan of gore and guts.
-Or I like romantic comedies.-
What I really don’t like, and have just stopped watching altogether are movies based on books that I liked. My reasons are as follows:
1)They are never as good as the books.
2)My mind is then poisoned with movie images that I can never shake, which is extra lame because of the first reason.
3)I don’t actually read a ton of books where stuff gets blown up, so I don’t really have to worry about overlap there.
4)I do read books full of suspense. Suspense in books is fine, I just read faster, I like it. Suspense in movies irritates me and I ALWAYS jump. I hate jumping.
5) I also hate nightmares. It takes a bit in books to give me nightmares, Steven King gives me nightmares. When it comes to movies I could probably manage a nightmare after watching the Sandlot. Therefore half the books I read are movies I would never see for fear of nightmares.
6)If I want to have deep thoughts about something I’ll read a book. Movies are, in my opinion, for open mouthed, drooling, mindless, entertainment. Therefore if I’ve read a book that requires any sort of brain power I’m not interested in seeing it on the screen.
When in comes to movies I didn’t love Seven Pounds (way too much thinking) I won’t be watching the Time Travelers Wife, or Inkheart (because making a movie about a book like that is just wrong) and don’t even get me started on Harry Potter…
But I did really like this book. So much so that if it becomes a movie I’ll never – ever – watch it.
Would I recommend it? Yes!
I liked this book for the same reasons you do. Nice pick.
Did you read the rest of the series? I just finished Bloodhound and I’m waiting for Mastiff. Bloodhound was good but I liked Terrier better.
I’ve now read Mastiff as well.
I really enjoyed them all but Terrier is still my favorite of the three.
[…] introduction to Tamora Pierce was in her Beka Cooper series. (You can read a review/movie rant here where I sort of talk about Terrier.) I was hooked and then delighted to discover another two dozen books by the same author, many set […]